Cotton Clouds – 100% cotton square pads

4 Reviews

1. 

   boastfulRice4

   Reply

   I was interested in purchasing Cotton Clouds because it was mentioned as a dupe for Shiseido Facial Cotton. Shi cottons are my HG but I didn’t order enough to get me through to the next Sephora sale so I figured it was a great time to give the Cotton Clouds a go.

   Each package of Cotton Clouds (as stated on the front of the package) “may be separated into 200 individual pieces.” I purchased a three pack from Amazon for $11.99 plus $2.92 shipping (total $14.91). While I am happier with Cotton Clouds than the performance of a drugstore cotton round for facial use, I am not sold on the claim that these are a dupe for Shi cottons. Here are the differences that I noticed…

   *Cotton Clouds (1 7/8 in x 2 3/8 in.) are a tiny bit smaller than Shi (2 1/8 x 2 1/2).
   *The layers of Cotton Clouds peel apart easier than Shi – which to some may be useful. I find it frustrating when I reach for a cotton and get either half of one or more than one. I’ve used one full package of Cotton Clouds and not once have I picked up just ONE cotton from the stack. It does say on the package, “Pick it thick or thin,” so the separation of cottons seems to be a selling point.
   *If there is any type of snag in the Cotton Cloud or uneven texture on your face that causes the cotton to snag, it will leave cotton across the face. I have never experienced this with a Shi cotton.
   *Cotton Clouds are a bit rougher in texture than Shi cottons. On occasion as I’m swiping a Cotton Cloud across my face I will find a rough spot within the cotton – like a impurity in the cotton.

   Although it may come off as if there are more negatives than positives with this review, please keep in mind that I am considering Cotton Clouds to be an acceptional value when it comes to price. I have heard these mentioned to be sold at Merle Norman shops but cannot personally confirm – so availability depends on if you plan to order from Amazon or can find these in person, or if you prefer to grab a pack of Shi cottons when you swing into Sephora. I did like the packaging of Cotton Clouds more than Shi as the bag has a zip top and can be resealed.

   I will finish the additional packages I have but plan to replenish my stock of Shi cottons during Sephora sales.

2. 

   jubilantPiglet5

   Reply

   I was interested in Cotton Clouds because they advertised that they could be separated to desired thickness and I wanted really thin cotton pads so not as much product (specifically, toner) would be absorbed.

   I didn’t find what I was looking for because they come as little rectangular pads, and like any cotton pad have two sides to them. Therefore, they can only be separated into two or else you’re rubbing a bunch of lint on your face. Since these are quite thick and fluffy, separating them into two makes them somewhat less dense but I find they still absorb a normal amount of product. A whole one absorbs an exorbitant amount of product.

   I did like the resealable bag with the large opening (no thin tube like with cotton rounds) but ultimately this product doesn’t fit my needs. I’ve turned to muslin cloths, which as a bonus are reusable.

3. 

   gloomySeafowl5

   Reply

   Wow! I’m glad to know you can get this at Amazon. I still have remaining stock from the Cosmetic Center (gone a LONG time). I have always used these for removing polish and as the package says, you can pick it thick or thin.

4. 

   cynicalPie8

   Reply

   Cotton Clouds can be bought at Amazon for 3.99, you get 220 count.
   Why are these cotton pads so different I thought? They are indeed soft, maybe too soft? I compared these to Target’s Up & Up brand.
   First test – Facial toner. On one side my usual the round pad and the CC on the other. My round pad got a whole in it and I had to apply more toner to clean my neck. The Cotton Clouds held up with one application of toner. CC wins.
   Next; the nail polish remover test – On one side a cotton ball against the CC and here’s where it gets dicey, removing two coats of polish with micro glitter and one top coat!
   I needed to use three cotton balls on one foot plus of course more remover. The Cotton Clouds, (and I still can’t believe this), only one needed to remove all that polish, no holes, tears, or cotton fuzz left behind! I did have to put more remover on but who cares. The winner is Cotton Clouds! I’ll be re-ordering!