Big Fatty Mascara – Waterproof

10 Reviews

1. 

   soreShads1

   Reply

   This one’s entered my regular mascara rotation a few years ago and never really made it out. It’s excellent. Gives you extra volumes, without being too dramatic if you only wear one coat – so you can wear it in the daytime and build it up for the evening. Not so sure about the waterproofing, but otherwise very happy with it. One tube also lasts quite a long time.

2. 

   ashamedPretzels3

   Reply

   I wish this was still a thing. I had probably three or four tubes of it before it was discontinued and I miss it a lot! 🙁

3. 

   worldlyLeopard6

   Reply

   This will forever be my favorite mascara! It does everything a mascara should do without flaking and smudging. The only negative thing about this is how expensive it is, but to be honest, it’s worth every penny!

4. 

   excludedIcecream7

   Reply

   This is the second time I bought this mascara I am a mascara junkie and will try all kinds because I love them so:) I really like this product it lasts but you can’t touch your eyes or it will crumble when it’s dry. It needs to be more slick instead of dry on the lashes. It does however in my case make my lashes look super fat and long.

   I have good eyelashes so I have a love with mascara I actually used the non waterproof first I think that one is better. I do like this though so what If I have to check every now and then you can’t expect perfection. You can however expect a good product that does do what it say’s give you big fat lashes. I have used many mascara’s and only bought another brand again (Landcome).

   I do love my Big Fatty but I will be purchasing the non waterproof in the future. I do like it though.

5. 

   solemnLion6

   Reply

   This mascara, despite the gigantic brush, does a superior job of making my thin, wispy blonde eyelashes look long, thick, and dark. Just a couple swipes and I’m ready to party! No flakes, no clumping, no smell. 🙂 However, I wouldn’t recommend this for everyday use as it is very dramatic and is more of a special occasion mascara than a staple one. Overall, it’s a really good mascara. 🙂

6. 

   lovesickOrange4

   Reply

   This was a big, “fatty” fail haha. The packaging is psychedelic and cool, no doubt, but the mascara itself is not. The wand is way too big and long and it prevents control of the mascara. the product is very thin and gives you extremely natural lashes. It’s a shaaame :p Waterproof wise, it’s great

7. 

   empathicSeahorse7

   Reply

   I was a little if-y when I saw how big the brush was. But I was completely happy with the outcome. It does not run and gave a ton of volume/length when used with a curler, gave mid used without one. No raccoon eyes for me!

8. 

   brainyEagle3

   Reply

   Very disappointing. It clumps and the wand does not help AT ALL.

   However, it is very waterproof. It’ll stay on through anything.

9. 

   troubledCod3

   Reply

   So I bought this for 5 USD off of UD website, they were clearencing . I read the reviews, I was hopeful but doubtful. OMG Yes the brush is large, yes the formula is wet but overall I’m loving it. It hasn’t flaked or ran, I didn’t look like a raccoon. It gave me ton of volume & a little length. For 5 bucks it’s totally worth it & I love the psychedelic packaging too cute.

10. 

    culturedCordial3

    Reply

    More like big fat disappointment!! 🙁
    I have naturally longer, but stick straight eye lashes and I need something to give them volume.

    When I applied this to my recently curled lashes it made them go back to straight. Did nothing but weigh them down, no added volume or length.

    Thankfully I bought it on sale from Urban Decay so it wasnt full price… but now its just going to sit around in my makeup drawer taking up space.
    Only positive was that it left my eye lashes soft and not crunchy.