Supercat Skinny Eyeliner

10 Reviews

1. 

   peacefulCordial4

   Reply

   If only if the black was super black, this would be a holy grail. The formula is great and the applicator makes a wing effortless. But I have to apply black eyeshadow over it to make it pop more. Dont get me wrong its black but not popping black.

2. 

   euphoricApples7

   Reply

   I was so excited to try this eyeliner and it works great for one eye and then after it seems to run out for the other one.

   Yesterday I was able to do my wing liner soooo good, I was so pumped for the selfie I was going to take and then when I tried doing the other eye it didn’t work, the color seemed to have faded… I was about to throw it out but I put it horizontal in my bag hoping that would do something and just tried it again now and same thing just happened… I’m here writing this review with one perfect winged eye and a sad eye ????

3. 

   similarCamel7

   Reply

   I really wanted to like this product but unfortunately it is just not pigmented enough. The felt tip allows for easy application but the colour is not dark enough and it doesn’t stay on all day.

   I often use this liner to draw on a wing then overline it with a more pigmented eyeliner.

4. 

   mercifulCake7

   Reply

   I wanted to like this product so much but I don’t know how this product gets such good reviews. I bought mine from target for $12 USD so converted to CAD it’s $15-16.
   First the tip is not flexible, so be careful not to scratch your eyelid; but it makes it easier to apply the perfect pointed wing. However, It doesn’t apply consistently, like it’s almost skipping/ patchy.
   Lastly, it have no staying power whatsoever. I wish I could’ve just saved up my $ and bought my usual Stila stay all day or kat Von d. If you’re looking for a product that stays on your oily eyelids, don’t buy this.

5. 

   amazedThrush4

   Reply

   This liner is fantastic!!!!! I prefer this over the Stila Stay All Day Liner for the following reasons: it’s worth the money ( and compared to Stila so much more affordable), it doesn’t seem to dry up, it’s really black, it stays put. I like it so much I purchased 2 more backups so I will never be without it.

6. 

   amazedFlamingo3

   Reply

   I feel so bad leaving a terrible review because I live for Soap and Glory products. I got this eyeliner after hearing such good reviews from friends, family and other make-up lovers, and I was so excited. It is a great price and it is as black as a black eyeliner gets… However, it just doesn’t work for me. I wore this eyeliner for a day and it never dried and constantly marked my upper eyelid leaving marks in my eye shadow and it just didn’t have the sharp finish I wanted. I tried using make-up setting spray on it and this made the situation a lot worse, making the liner wetter than before. I tried a plethora of eye primers and again, no joy. I think this is down to me having oily eyelids with a little bit of overlap, but I was very disappointed with the final product and I would not recommend to anyone with a hooded lid or anyone with a slightly oily complexion. Very disappointed.

7. 

   wearyBuzzard2

   Reply

   This eyeliner is by far one of the easiest eyeliners to use. It glides on great. It’s got an amazing “pen tip” that is firm enough unlike other eyeliner pens I’ve used -giving this eyeliner a huge plus in my book-making it easy to draw or apply the line without the tip budging in different unwanted directions. One of the best eyeliners I’ve ever used and would definitely recommend it! I have it in “black” and it also dries quickly so you don’t have to wait for it to dry and worry about it getting everywhere if you blink. (You know what I mean!! lol)

8. 

   truthfulTuna2

   Reply

   Was recommended this by a friend I used to work with in dept store cosmetics. He is now a BA for Walgreens and swears by Supercat. I have been suitably impressed! I’m honestly surprised by lukewarm reviews, since I have found this to apply inky-black (even over powder shadows! no clogging on the felt tip!) and have excellent longevity, especially for a non-waterproof formula. my go-to liquid liner used to be L’oreal Lineur Intense, but this is the one I consistently grab now. I usually rock a vintage-inspired cateye flick and this does it quicker and cleaner than anything else in my arsenal, without breaking the bank.

9. 

   artisticPudding8

   Reply

   This product would be perfect, if only it had staying power. II would most def recommend this to a beginner- it is super-easy to apply. It glides on and has good, buildable colour. Does not dry out during application which is a common problem with felt-tips (MAC is a nightmare). Only one, but very important, drawback: it does not stay put. It leaks onto eyelids (a problem I’ve never had before with eyeliners) and you lose the catflick by the time you reach the afternoon, which is very annoying at work. You shouldn’t need to re-apply eyeliner during the day. What a shame. I love it every time I apply, then it disappoints during the day.

10. 

    hushedPonie6

    Reply

    I wanted to love this… I love S&G products and I love felt-tip eyeliners. The application of the felt is so easy but unfortunately the colour & consistency lets the product down. I’ve used it three times and every time when its on my skin it looks like it’s ran out. I’ve tried a primer underneath, on and off an eyeshadow base and neither makes any difference. I’ve tried layering it and it makes no difference.
    The product creases & smudges during wear, and for the price, I’d much rather go back to using my usual bourjois liner.
    It’s a real shame – the packaging & look is fabulous but the actual usage lets itself down.