gel eyeliner pencil

5 Reviews

1. 

   selfishPiglet7

   Reply

   I purchase this eyeliner regularly (along with the retractable version). As someone who has monolids, it’s hard to find eyeliners which won’t smudge, have strong pigmentation and which doesn’t transfer. I’ve used eyeliners from Silkygirl, Maybelline, Essence, Elianto and other brands but it didn’t work for me.

   Occasionally (in Malaysia), they’d release a “buy one free one” set, with a limited edition color like henna brown, a silvery taupe color, purple, etc (which I think is great). I do wish that they would make it part of the regular line which only has black and brown.

   I was wearing this eyeliner when I broke down and cried a lot once. Besides some smudging, it remained intact which really shocked me. I don’t think it’s waterproof though.

   The pigmentation is incredibly strong. The black is more of a pure black than a smokey grey black. The brown is very intense as well (but you can definitely differentiate from the black one).

   Due to my eye shape (kinda like puppy eyes), it does slightly smudge in the corners of my eyes but that happens with every eyeliner I’ve ever used so it doesn’t bother me.

   There was an instance when the eyeliner melted (it was during a heatwave, I left it on my vanity desk in a hot room), so remember to keep yours in a cool place.

   Pros:
   – Strong pigmentation
   – Barely smudges
   – Sweat proof
   – Lasts all day without fading
   – Good quality
   – Good packaging

   Cons:
   – Needs to be sharpened (you can get the retractable one instead, it’s basically the same product in different form)
   – Kinda pricey (without the buy-one-free-one promotion)
   – Only available in several countries in SEA

2. 

   goofyFalcon3

   Reply

   This is my holy grail eyeliner. It’s cheap. It’s pigmented. It’s waterproof. It lasts all day.

   I live in a humid country and throughout the day, I tend to get oily (my eyelid area is no exception) ’cause of the hot hellish weather. Yet, this thing stays on my upper lids (the only area I apply it). It would fade a little (the outer lines), ’cause of (extreme) sweat or scrubbing, but never full on smudging. Note that I don’t even use eye primer.

   You’d need a sharpener for this, which they sell also sell in IN2IT stalls. Additional cost. And yup, sharpening it does waste product. That’s a little sad. This pencil gel liner is soft and creamy, too (and I don’t know if that’s a pro or a con). Also, sometimes, I’d forget that I have makeup on and rub my eyes. And every time I did that, I’d get to see a little bit of the product on my fingers. It’s gel liner, and I tend to not wait (for it to dry) before applying another (thick) layer of this so maybe that’d explain why. And oh, this has never caused me panda eyes. These cons aren’t a big deal for me, really. I’ve had this for almost a year and mine has not dried.

   I have the brown shade of this. And it’s perfect for rocking a softer and more natural look (than black eyeliner). Wish they’d have colors in nude or white, though. So I could use them on my waterline.

3. 

   pridefulPup9

   Reply

   its a good eyeliner. sweat proof & tear proof. doesnt budge for hours. cheap & good quality

4. 

   artisticMandrill9

   Reply

   This is a really awesome eyeliner! My sister recommended this to me and I’m happy to say that I am not disappointed. It is a gel eyeliner but in pencil form making this so convenient! The colour is highly pigmented and glides on very smoothly. It takes a while to dry, but once it does, it rarely smudges. I’ve tried it on long hot humid days and it has lasted for at least 12 hours! It is also waterproof (i’m a cryer, so yay! lol). The package comes with a free sharpener too so thats cool. However, this brand is currently available in Malaysia, Philippines and Thailand only. It only costs around 7 USD. I would never trade this in for any of the high end cosmetic brands because IMO this is way better and easier to use 🙂

5. 

   kindFlamingo0

   Reply

   In2it gel eyeliner pencil is a gel liner in pencil form, so I was surprised when I saw “gel liner” written on it, so I think it was really nice because the only cons I find from gel liner are that they require another brush to use and that they sometimes dry out easily, so those cons were eliminated. On the product itself, it lasted quite long (for about 10-12 hours before I washed it off, but then again, I was just at home, lounging about and trying to experiment my new eyeliner). On the day I actually used it, it lasted about 5 hours, still pretty good considering it was one of the hottest days ever, but it smeared. It has intense pigmentation so you only need one swipe, but it was super soft so you need to be careful and have a light hand for it to not be too thick. It promised to be waterproof, but it was not. It was close though. It also came with a sharpener which was really great. The reason why I think I would not buy again, was because I don’t think I’ll ever get a hand light enough to not make the line thin enough for my taste.