ColorStay Liquid Liner

10 Reviews

1. 

   innocentPaella6

   Reply

   This product burns my eyelids! Have sensitive skin so not for me. Works for my mom though- she’s used it 10+ years and it’s very long-wearing, black, and sharp.

2. 

   ecstaticWildfowl8

   Reply

   This has been my go-to eyeliner ever since I have discovered it! Absolutely love it. It lasts all day, goes over eyeshadow wonderfully, and has great pigment. Some people complain about the stiff applicator brush, but I find that it gives you more control. If you are just starting to experiment with doing wings, this is perfect because the brush will not move from under you like the skinnier brushes will. I do winged eyeliner daily and I do find that my wings tend to be thicker with this product due to its brush, but personally I do prefer thicker wings. For people with sensitive skin like myself, this eyeliner is also great. I have had experience with some eyeliners burning my eyelids, but I have never had that issue with this product. Definitely recommend!

3. 

   superiorChamois4

   Reply

   My tried and true eyeliner, what a classic! Goes on smooth, stays put all day. Waterproof as well. The price is wonderful and the packaging is great! Will always repurchase!

4. 

   artisticLlama6

   Reply

   I found this eyeliner in discount and after the very good reviews I decided to give it a try after I already had decided to never use liquid eyeliner again. I got the color black brown.
   It is just great! The small firm tip allows to draw from a superfine line to a very dramatic look, it dries fast and doesn’t rub off my oily eyelids. Lasts all day, even a nap.

5. 

   enviousApricots5

   Reply

   I mostly love this product: (1) the precise application with the stiff brush at the end and (2) the color going on thick (I don’t have to reapply layers to get the black I want). (3) I can use it for a thin line or a thick line. Also, (4) this product does not “sting” my eyelids like some eyeliners have done in the past.

   My reasons for not fully loving this product are: (1) After some uses, the brush applicator hairs become loose – in other words, I have to use tweezers to pull out some stray hairs peeking out at the top of the brush, and that’s slightly annoying but would be more annoying if I didn’t notice them and proceeded to apply the liner with these stray hairs dragging very tiny lines of black around my main black line that I’m trying to apply.

6. 

   zestyLocust1

   Reply

   My eyes are extremely sensitive, and I have a hard time finding eyeliner that doesn’t irritate. I discovered this one several years ago, and quickly became my favorite. I tightline from underneath the lash line to frame my eyes and give the appearance of thicker lash roots, without looking like obvious makeup. I love the short, stiff brush (felt tip?) that allows for complete control without flopping around. I dot pigment between the roots of individual lashes, and then I connect the dots. It never smears all over the water line. Bonus points for a brush I don’t have to wash.

   I have very fair, pink-porcelain skin with dark ash blonde hair (10% grey), and Black is not too harsh when applied under the lash roots. It adds a subtle frame, more than an obvious line. Still, I would be over the moon if Revlon offered this liner in a blue-tinted sooty grey. (The Brown was too warm for me.) The bottle goes into my daily makeup bag, and it has never leaked or dried out.

   This product stays on all day–though it would fade if I had a good cry. Unlike other brands’ gel formulas, the Revlon ColorStay Liquid Liner easily washes away at night with my usual cleanser.

7. 

   humorousCur7

   Reply

   This is the best liquid eyeliner out there. Does not smudge like others. I have used cheaper brands through to Dior, Mac and Chanel. This does not run. I have no reactions to it.
   This is still my favourite after more than 10 years.
   I don’t use the newer thin brush – those brushes are too thin and flexible.
   This is like a stiffer, easier to apply brush.
   My go to liner and couldn’t live without it. I always have at least 2x of these – one for my handbag, one for at home/work.

8. 

   dearJaguar7

   Reply

   I bought this in the black brown but it stings my eyes. It’s a hard felt tip and wears away in the inner corners. Not a fan

9. 

   annoyedMeerkat2

   Reply

   This was my go-to liner for a long time. When I was getting into the winged eyeliner game, this was the liner I learned the most while with. Now that I’m much better at application, I’m seriously considering going back to this one because it’s easier to use than the pen eyeliner I’m currently working with. That’s the major reason why I adore it. The wand tip is firm and I feel like I have total control over my liner and don’t have to spend forever on it.

   I was pretty impressed with the color. The black was very black after I shook the tube a bit and applied. If I needed something darker, I would just apply another coat. Easy to fix any mistakes as it didn’t just stick to the eyelid once applied, which was nice.

   I will say that you can tell when this eyeliner is on it’s way to being done. The pigment gets very light, but even then I was able to get the last drops out of this one and then go over my liner with some black eyeshadow.

10. 

    drearyMeerkat2

    Reply

    Oh god, I love this stuff SO much!!! Definite HG eyeliner. I will seriously cry if they stop making it, and sometimes it’s really hard to find, I can never find it at Ulta anymore and it worries me. It makes me really sad when I see reviews that people hate this or it didn’t work out because this is just perfect. I used to use the NYC liner when I was like 15 and then at some point got this in high school and have literally never looked back or tried anything else and i’m now 23. I always wear a cat eye when I wear makeup and I can get a thinner line if I chose for work or can get it thicker for night looks. I get such crisp, dark lines with this and never have to go over with another coat. The only time it gets a little patchy is when its at the end of it’s life and when the felt tip gets fuzzy. I can use this for probably 2-3 months before I have to switch but a lot of the time I keep a back up so when it starts going bad I can just toss it and switch. I use the blackest black shade I believe. So nice, dark and matte black. This isn’t super watery, it has a hint of thickness to it. I also like how i can get a thinner line towards the front and thicker as I go out. Also the tiny point is easy for filling in the small gap between your lashes and lid. I personally prefer felt tips over the brush tips. It lasts about 8 hours for me, can transfer a little if I rub my eye in the corner or if I get sweaty but when I use a setting spray(UD all nighter) I don’t typically have transfer and looks amazing at the end of my work day. I do have to keep my eye closed when I first apply it though and let it dry for a second otherwise I get a ring of it on my crease. I typically use coconut oil to take it off but if I don’t, it can take a little bit of work with a makeup wipe to remove. I think this is less than $10 which is just great. Please never discontinue this revlon!!