Sugar Cookie Eye Shadow Palette

1 Review

1. 

   ashamedTeal8

   Reply

   This is a fun little palette. Cute, sturdy packaging and pretty, wearable colors. It has a vanilla cookie scent that surprisingly lingers a little longer than most scented Too Faced palettes… it’s on your eyes though so it isn’t too intrusive.

   I enjoy how most of these shades perform with the exceptions of the icy/glittery white shade and the darkest plummy black. They both appear pretty patchy and have thicker glitter particles with a sheerer base color. I expect they will probably require a thicker primer or glitter glue to get the nicest look out of them. Too Faced has very similar shades to these both in other palettes that are of better quality than these.

   Still, there is more that I like than dislike. It’s easy to make quick looks without a ton of effort or precision. A lot of palettes are doing the “warm blush” thing right now like this one. But, this is more subtle and less “rabbit eye.” I like to pair it with a basic all matte palette (currenty Viseart Matte or Tarte Clay Play 1) together they fill any versatility concerns I have with it.

   I wasn’t expecting very much because the reviews I read have been pretty mixed, leaning towards negative. I think it really depends on your personal tastes more so than actual product quality. For that reason, although I would recommend, I would suggest waiting until it’s on sale and not paying full retail.